The last 2 places we looked at were Lowes (specifically their Blanco Leblon granite) and Granite and Cabinet Depot . Lowes granite was one of the prettier ones we looked at, but price ruled it out. Then the last place we looked, Granite and Cabinet Depot was recommended by one of our neighbours who had his kitchen done by them and was happy with price/quality. Their granite was comparable price to the other places we looked, but the selection was not quite as good as the other places.
So, here are the finalists for our granite. We were torn between Black Galaxy and Kashmir White. While shopping we found out that Kashmir White is a couple hundred dollars cheaper than black granite. We're now leaning more towards it, but we're still a bit worried about it staining.
Right now 3 is in the lead. The price looks good and in general Toronto Granite made a better impression on us than the other places we visited.